Secure Your Law Firm Communications

Your law firm receives an email from a client wanting to change their banking instructions for an upcoming transaction. The message comes from the client’s usual address, references the correct transaction, and includes updated account information. Everything appears legitimate, so your staff arrange the transfer.

Unfortunately, the message came from a cybercriminal who gained access to the client’s email account. Your firm has now transferred trust funds to a fraudulent bank account, and recovering the money could prove difficult (if not impossible).

This type of fraud, known as business email compromise (BEC), is a serious cyber security threat to Canadian law firms. Knowing how criminals manipulate email communications and payment instructions can help you protect your clients, your trust accounts, and your firm’s reputation.

Why Do Cybercriminals Target Law Firm Trust Accounts?

Law firms handle a lot of money through trust accounts, especially during real estate transactions, business acquisitions, estate administration, and settlement payments. Unfortunately, criminals can intercept communications about these transactions and redirect funds.

Unlike ransomware attacks, which can lock users out of their computer systems, email account takeovers can remain undetected while criminals monitor correspondence and collect information. It’s literally a waiting game: attackers may spend days reviewing your messages before attempting to redirect a payment.

According to PracticePRO, a growing number of LAWPRO-insured Ontario law firms are experiencing unauthorized withdrawals from trust and general accounts, including one incident involving $1.6 million removed through eight transactions over three days. The consequences, however, can extend beyond stolen funds. A successful attack can compromise confidential information, trigger regulatory reporting obligations, and damage professional relationships, sometimes irreparably.

How Do Email Account Takeovers Happen?

Cybercriminals use several techniques to gain access to law firm email accounts. Once inside, they can read correspondence, impersonate legitimate users, and manipulate payment instructions.

Phishing Emails and Stolen Credentials

Phishing attacks trick employees into revealing their usernames, passwords, or authentication information. Criminals create convincing messages that appear to originate from trusted sources like technology providers, colleagues, or clients, and wait for a response.

For example, a law clerk might receive an email appearing to come from Microsoft 365, warning that their account needs immediate verification. The message directs them to a fraudulent login page that captures their credentials.

Once it’s received, criminals then use the stolen information to access the employee’s mailbox. Some attacks also intercept authentication sessions, allowing criminals to bypass conventional multifactor authentication (MFA).

Compromised Client or Third-Party Accounts

Your firm’s email system doesn’t have to be compromised for a payment diversion scam to succeed. These cybercriminals can do just as much damage by accessing the email account of a client, real estate agent, opposing lawyer, or another participant in a transaction. Because messages originate from legitimate accounts, recipients may have difficulty identifying the deception.

Email Impersonation and Lookalike Domains

Some hackers create email addresses that closely resemble legitimate law firm addresses. For example, they might replace one letter in a firm’s domain name or register a similar-looking address. The fraudulent message may include genuine transaction information obtained through earlier correspondence or stolen documents. Familiar names, email signatures, and transaction references can make the communication appear trustworthy.

How Do Criminals Redirect Trust Account Payments?

After accessing an email account, the attackers search for upcoming transactions involving money transfers. They review closing dates, settlement agreements, banking instructions, and correspondence between lawyers and clients. Once they identify an opportunity, they interfere with the payment arrangements. Their objective is to convince someone with payment authority to transfer funds into an account they control.

Changing Banking Instructions

With this approach, a criminal impersonates a client, lawyer, or financial institution and requests that funds be transferred to a different account. The message may claim that the original account has been closed or that updated instructions are necessary to complete the transaction.

Without independent verification, your staff could send money directly to an account controlled by the attacker. Once transferred, the funds may be moved between accounts, making recovery difficult.

Hijacking Existing Email Conversations

An attacker who controls a participant’s mailbox may reply to an existing conversation, retaining the previous correspondence and familiar email signatures. This makes the fraudulent instructions appear to be part of an established discussion. Employees who recognize the sender and transaction may approve the transfer without questioning the changes.

Concealing Fraudulent Communications

Attackers can create mailbox rules that redirect incoming messages, delete notifications, or move correspondence into hidden folders. These changes allow criminals to monitor communications while reducing the chance that the account holder will discover unauthorized activity. By the time your firm identifies the intrusion, the fraudulent transfer may already have occurred. The attacker may also retain access to confidential client information and correspondence.

What Are the Warning Signs of Email Payment Fraud?

An authentic-looking email address doesn’t guarantee that a payment request is legitimate. Your employees should recognize warning signs that require additional verification before any funds are transferred. They include:

  • Unexpected Banking Changes: A client or colleague requests new payment instructions shortly before funds are scheduled for transfer.
  • Urgent Payment Demands: The sender insists that the transfer must occur immediately to prevent delays or penalties.
  • Unusual Communication Patterns: A familiar contact suddenly refuses telephone conversations or requests email-only communication.
  • Unfamiliar Account Information: The receiving account belongs to an unexpected individual, company, or financial institution.
  • Suspicious Email Activity: Your employees discover unfamiliar forwarding rules, missing messages, or security notifications they didn’t initiate.

Even when none of these warning signs appears, your firm should independently verify payment instructions before transferring trust funds. Criminals with access to genuine email accounts can imitate normal communication patterns without raising immediate suspicion.

How Can Your Law Firm Prevent Email Account Takeovers?

To protect your trust accounts, you need both technical safeguards and internal payment verification procedures. Both are necessary because cybercriminals can compromise accounts outside your firm’s network.

Implement Strong Email Security

Your firm should establish security controls that restrict unauthorized access and identify suspicious activity. These measures reduce opportunities for criminals to compromise email accounts and interfere with financial transactions. Recommended safeguards include:

  • Phishing-Resistant MFA: Use security keys or device-bound passkeys to protect email accounts against credential theft and authentication interception.
  • Email Authentication: Configure SPF, DKIM, and DMARC to reduce unauthorized use of your firm’s email domain.
  • Account Monitoring: Review unusual login activity, unauthorized forwarding rules, and unexpected changes to account permissions.
  • Access Restrictions: Limit administrative privileges and remove access when employees leave the firm.
  • Security Updates: Maintain current software versions and security patches across employee devices.

These precautions should be reviewed regularly as your firm’s technology and staffing change. Monitoring is particularly important because attackers may continue accessing compromised accounts without triggering obvious warnings.

Verify Payment Instructions Independently

It’s always a good idea to verify wire transfer instructions through a separate communication channel before transferring funds. Never rely on telephone numbers included in an email requesting payment changes. If a criminal controls the sender’s account, the message may contain a telephone number that connects your employees directly to the attacker.

You should also establish written procedures requiring staff to confirm the recipient’s identity, banking information, and authorization before releasing trust funds. Include a second-person review for transfers to reduce the risk of unauthorized payments.

Train Your Employees to Recognize Fraud

Lawyers, law clerks, assistants, and accounting employees should undergo regular cyber security training that addresses the following:

  • Phishing techniques
  • Configure SPF, DKIM, and DMARC to reduce unauthorized use of your firm’s email domain.
  • Fraudulent banking instructions
  • Suspicious login notifications
  • Internal reporting procedures

Encourage staff to report suspicious communications immediately rather than attempting to investigate potential account compromises themselves.

What Should You Do If Your Firm’s Email Is Compromised?

If you discover an email account takeover, contact your IT provider immediately to investigate and contain the intrusion. Early intervention can prevent further unauthorized access and improve your chances of recovering diverted funds. Your response should include the following steps:

  • Secure the Compromised Account: Revoke unauthorized sessions, reset credentials, and review authentication settings.
  • Remove Unauthorized Changes: Delete malicious forwarding rules and unauthorized authentication methods.
  • Investigate Email Activity: Identify fraudulent messages, affected clients, and compromised confidential information.
  • Contact Your Financial Institution: Report unauthorized transfers immediately and request assistance stopping or recovering the funds.
  • Report the Fraud: Preserve relevant records and report suspected criminal activity to police and the Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre.
  • Review Reporting Obligations: Assess your firm’s professional, insurance, and privacy reporting requirements.

Your firm should also determine how the attacker gained access and address the security weaknesses involved. Reviewing the incident can help prevent the same attack from succeeding again.

Protect Your Law Firm’s Email and Trust Accounts Now

Email account takeovers can threaten your firm’s operations. But by combining hands-on verification procedures with in-depth cyber security systems, you can create a sound defense against intrusions. The objective is not to detect fraud only after a suspicious transfer request is received – with the right measures, you can prevent the request from reaching your inbox in the first place.